Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted in $25M Ethereum MEV exploit case
Author: Crypffalo Research · 03:54 17/11/2026
A Manhattan federal judge granted the Peraire-Bueno brothers' motion for acquittal on all three counts, closing the first U.S. criminal case built around an Ethereum MEV strategy.

A federal judge in Manhattan has acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, the MIT-educated brothers accused of draining about $25 million from Ethereum MEV bots. U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke granted the defense's motion for acquittal, according to a report published at 3:30 p.m. ET on Nov 16.
TokenPost reports the brothers were cleared on all three counts: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering. The ruling is a major turn in the first U.S. criminal case targeting a maximal extractable value (MEV) strategy.
Key takeaways
- Ruling: Judge Jessica Clarke granted the defense's acquittal motion after the 2025 jury trial ended in a mistrial.
- Charges: Not guilty on wire fraud, wire fraud conspiracy and money laundering conspiracy.
- Amount: About $25 million was taken from MEV bots in April 2023, in roughly 12 seconds.
- Core reason: Prosecutors failed to prove a material misrepresentation, a required element of wire fraud.
- Why it matters: The decision lowers the criminal risk of onchain strategies that exploit how a protocol works.
How the case unfolded
Prosecutors alleged that in April 2023 the brothers used bait transactions to lure Ethereum sandwich bots. They then exploited a weakness in an MEV-Boost relay to see and reorder those trades, pocketing roughly $25 million from the bots.
The Justice Department treated this as fraud and arrested the pair in May 2024. The defense argued the brothers simply played by the rules of an open system in which MEV bots themselves hunt for an edge over other users.
Key dates in the case:
- April 2023: About $25 million is drained from MEV bots in roughly 12 seconds.
- May 2024: The brothers are arrested and charged in Manhattan.
- November 2025: The jury deadlocks and the judge declares a mistrial.
- Nov 16, 2026: The judge acquits both brothers on all three counts.

Why the judge acquitted
According to The Block, the question was not whether the strategy was improper or unethical, but whether it amounted to wire fraud. The judge found prosecutors had not shown any material misrepresentation in how the scheme was carried out.
The court also noted the trades did not take place on a regulated market where the alleged conduct is clearly prohibited. With the fraud theory gone, the money laundering conspiracy count built on it could not stand either.
Back in 2025, Coin Center described the prosecution as a massive overstep by authorities. Reports have not yet said how prosecutors plan to respond to the new ruling.
Crypffalo data view
Crypffalo's DeepDom data for the 24 hours to 3:00 a.m. GMT+7 on Nov 17 shows a largely flat market, though sellers stayed more aggressive in bitcoin futures.
- Price: BTC near $65,036 (+0.19%), ETH near $1,823 (−0.03%) → very small 24-hour moves.
- Liquidations: BTC saw $16.4 million in longs and $28.4 million in shorts liquidated; ETH saw $17.1 million and $20.6 million → shorts took more pain in both coins.
- Aggressive flows: BTC futures net −$190.8 million, BTC spot −$10.1 million; ETH futures +$32.0 million but ETH spot −$66.6 million → sellers dominated BTC futures and ETH spot.
- Order book ±1%: BTC showed $148.2 million in bids versus $164.9 million in asks; ETH was roughly balanced at $67.8 million and $66.1 million → BTC leaned slightly to the sell side.
The ruling landed after the data cutoff, so it is not reflected in these numbers. The data points to a market still driven by macro selling pressure rather than by this single legal headline. See also real-time liquidations.
What it means for crypto markets
On price, this is a precedent-setting legal story that is unlikely to move markets sharply on its own. Bitcoin is holding near $65,000, close to a four-month low, while traders focus on tech stocks and Nvidia's earnings.
- Bull case: The ruling eases fears among developers, searchers and onchain market makers of criminal charges simply for exploiting how a protocol works, a sentiment boost for DeFi and Ethereum.
- Risk case: Lawmakers or regulators could use the case to push for MEV-specific rules, since general criminal statutes proved hard to apply.
The policy backdrop is also tough after the CLARITY market structure bill failed in the Senate. That makes it likely disputes like this will keep being settled in court rather than through new legislation.
What to watch next
- Any response from federal prosecutors in Manhattan and whether they pursue other options.
- Reactions from policy groups such as Coin Center and from Ethereum developers.
- FOMC minutes and Nvidia's earnings this week, the two factors driving market sentiment. Check the economic calendar.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is MEV?
MEV is the value block builders or bots can capture by adding, removing or reordering transactions in a block. Sandwich trading bots are a common form of MEV on Ethereum.
Which charges were the Peraire-Bueno brothers acquitted of?
They were found not guilty on all three counts: wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
Did the ruling lift the ETH price right away?
There is no sign of that so far, with ETH flat near $1,823. The ruling is mainly a long-term legal precedent for DeFi.
*This content is for information only and is not financial advice.*
Tags: Ethereum, MEV, Regulation, DeFi
Related articles
- Sky's USDS sees $1.5B USDC exodus after North Korea-linked flows report
- Fed's Musalem sees several rate hikes by spring 2027 as US retail sales beat forecasts
- Supreme Court rejects Custodia Bank's bid for Fed master account
- Lighter halts withdrawals after leaked API key drains $10.4 million
- Bitcoin Breaks Below $64,000, Ether Loses $1,800 as ETF Outflows Top $1 Billion
- Bitcoin falls below $66,000 to lowest since August as $1.47 billion liquidated